Trendpills
A 41-year-old man from Vandalia, Illinois, has been charged with first-degree murder and aggravated criminal sexual assault in the death of a 14-year-old girl who was reportedly under his care. The suspect, Arnold B. Rivera, also faces a charge of concealing a homicidal death in a case that has disturbed the southern Illinois community.
The victim was identified by her family as Kylie Toberman. According to Illinois State Police, she was reported missing on the morning of Friday, November 15, 2025. Her body was discovered later that same day, leading to a swift investigation that quickly focused on Rivera. He was taken into custody shortly after the discovery.
Charging documents filed in Fayette County outline the severe allegations against Rivera. He was described as the girl's "caretaker" in official reports. Prosecutors allege that he sexually assaulted the teenager and then strangled her with a pair of jumper cables. Following her death, Rivera allegedly attempted to conceal the crime by placing her body in a tote. These details, drawn from court filings, paint a grim picture of the events leading to the girl's death.
Rivera is currently being held at the Fayette County Jail pending further legal proceedings. During his initial court appearance, he was formally presented with the charges. The Illinois State Police Division of Criminal Investigation is leading the ongoing case, with assistance from the Vandalia Police Department and the Fayette County State’s Attorney’s office. The case will proceed through the state's judicial system, where prosecutors will present their evidence against Rivera. The investigation is still considered active as authorities continue to process the crime scene and gather information.
